Understanding the New HMRC Penalty System for VAT

20 October 2023

VAT image

In recent years, the UK's tax landscape has seen significant changes, and the Value Added Tax (VAT) system is no exception. The HM Revenue and Customs (HMRC) has introduced a new penalty system for VAT, aimed at simplifying and streamlining the process.

In this blog post, we'll delve into the key aspects of this new system and how it impacts businesses in the UK.


Why the Change?

The HMRC penalty system for VAT underwent a transformation primarily to improve clarity, fairness, and consistency in dealing with VAT non-compliance. The previous penalty system often left businesses confused and struggling to understand the fines levied, resulting in dissatisfaction and inefficiency. The new system is designed to address these issues.


Key Features of the New Penalty System

1. Two-Tier Approach: The new penalty system adopts a two-tier structure. The first tier covers minor VAT filing and payment mistakes, while the second tier focuses on serious non-compliance.


2. Points-Based System: HMRC introduces a points-based system to determine penalties. Businesses will accumulate points for infractions based on their frequency and severity. Penalties are then levied when a certain threshold of points is reached.


3. Prompt Disclosure: Businesses that promptly disclose their VAT errors will benefit from reduced penalties. This encourages transparency and proactive compliance.


4. Penalty Levels: The severity of penalties is linked to the number of points accrued, with higher point totals leading to increased fines. For businesses facing recurrent issues, the penalty system becomes more punitive.


Implications for Businesses

Understanding the new HMRC penalty system for VAT is crucial for businesses to avoid unnecessary fines and complications. Here are some key implications for businesses:


1. Compliance Matters: The new system emphasizes the importance of complying with VAT regulations. Regularly reviewing your VAT processes and ensuring accuracy is essential.


2. Prompt Disclosure: Businesses that make honest errors should promptly disclose them to HMRC. Timely disclosure can result in reduced penalties, fostering a culture of honesty.


3. Record-Keeping: Accurate and comprehensive record-keeping is essential to defend against penalties. Having organized VAT records can help in case of an HMRC audit.


4. Seek Professional Advice: It's advisable for businesses to seek professional advice, especially when dealing with complex VAT issues. VAT experts can help ensure compliance and reduce the risk of penalties.



The new HMRC penalty system for VAT represents a significant shift in how VAT non-compliance is addressed in the UK. It aims to simplify the process and encourage businesses to be more transparent and proactive in their dealings with HMRC. Businesses should stay informed about the system's nuances and adapt their practices to comply with the new regulations. By doing so, they can navigate the VAT landscape more effectively and avoid unnecessary penalties.


To find out how the firm can help with all of your VAT queries and support, please head over to our VAT page at: Value Added Tax and don't hesitate to Contact Us.